I read Roman’s slightly depressing post today “Commenting on Problogger does not improve your blog.” In it he has spent some quite considerable time researching commentators on Darren’s blog from six months ago to see if their traffic has significantly increased. His figures prove that it hasn’t, so he asserts that “Commenting on Problogger……” well, you’ve read the title!
The problem is, I feel Roman has completely missed the point. Commenting on Problogger can help improve your blog and blog traffic, as can writing guest posts or being active in forums.
BUT ONLY IF YOU HAVE GOOD QUALITY AND A DECENT QUANTITY OF CONTENT ON YOUR OWN SITE
Time and time again, Darren and other A list bloggers remind us that content is the most important aspect of blogging. You can do all the other stuff, you can be the King of Twitter, but if your content sucks, you’ll never have huge traffic. I have two sets of proof for this statement:
1/ I commented on Roman’s site that I was very happy with my traffic – like his, this blog has been going for around six months, and it’s receiving an average of more than 500 visitors per day. In that six months I’ve written 237 posts. Roman’s reply was very interesting – he has written 31 posts in the same period and his traffic is around 60 visitors a day.
There is a direct correlation between the number of posts I’ve written and the additional traffic I have received. Eight times the posts = eight times the traffic!
2/ You may know that at the same time as I started this blog, I also started two others. For this one and one other, we have worked hard on posting content. On the third (for reasons not relevant to this post) we haven’t. Have a look at the figures:
| Posts | Average Visitors | |
| This Blog | 237 | 552 |
| Travel Blog | 241 | 484 |
| Scuba Blog | 92 | 82 |
So, in our example you can clearly see the effect of lower posting on the statistics. Admittedly, this isn’t very scientific because the blogs are in different niches, although the writers are the same! But the message is clear:
Focus most of your blogging effort on content! Unless you disagree?
You might also enjoy:
1/ Eight ways to get blog traffic from Twitter
2/ How to create great content for your blog
3/ How much time do I need to write a blog?
Make money with your website using the DevHub.com free website builder. DevHub.com Turns Building Your Website into a Game.
I'm Mike CJ - welcome to Mike's Life! If you'd like to know more about me then please click About Mike.
If you're new here, please join the extraordinary community using the form above.
And come and say hello on Twitter @mikecj
"Mike's Life is where you can stay current with the life, thoughts, successes and failures of Mike Cliffe-Jones. Never knowingly ordinary, Mike shares as much as possible about his work as an author and CEO of two companies, as well as his enviable lifestyle on and in the oceans around The Canary Islands."
Content is king and readers
Content is king and readers expect fresh content when they visit a blog on a regular basis. The problem for me - and I assume this applies to others who hold down day jobs - is finding the time to properly research and write up an article that does the subject justice. Maybe I should stop sleeping :-)
Here's a tip Kevin - maybe
Here's a tip Kevin - maybe "batch" write the long, well researched posts, but intersperse them with short, easy to write ones. I did when I used to work in a normal job as well.
Posts like the one above can be "knocked out" in 20 minutes and it was just a quick response to something I read yesterday, so that's saved the long one I have ready for another day!
Mike
http://www.integralwebsolutions.co.za/Blog.aspx
I have to agree with you. Content is king.
Having said that I believe that comments are your loyal subjects.
Of course commenting on other blogs brings traffic to your site. The problem is that is does not bring the same amount of traffic to your site as the parent or original site.
I mean what did roman expect, thousands of visitors to his site, just because he is one of hundreds and thousands of other people that comment on Problogger.
I have proof that comenting on other blogs brings traffic to your site. THe things is that the more you comment on a wider selection, the more people will come. You could probably expect between 1-3 percent of your OWN traffic to come from different blogs, perhaps 1-3 percent from each blog. All depending on what niche, which blog, what your topics are, how often you comment, how relevant and usefull your comments are. A whole variaty of parameter will affect this.
Golden rule, comments are not about how you benefit your blog, but how you add value to other blogs.
Check out my post on comments and their value. http://www.integralwebsolutions.co.za/Blog/EntryId/264/Your-comments-mak...
@Robert Bravery To borrow
@Robert Bravery
To borrow Mike's phrase – “I feel you completely missed the point”.
I am not saying that by commenting on Problogger your blog should become a success because of all the traffic you will receive. My point has nothing to do with traffic coming back to a blog by posting comments.
I was showing that commentors on Problogger, even though they read his advice, do not increase their chances of success. A commentor who 1 year ago read Probloggers advice does not have a better chance of success with their blog then a commentor who read probloggers advice yesterday. This means that either the advice does not help or, more likely, Problogger commentors are not following the advice.
Fortunately Darren (from Problogger) made a nice long comment on the post explaining what he thinks might be going on.
Roman's last blog post... Commenting on Problogger Does Not Improve Your Blog
I think also, in direct
I think also, in direct relation to this, a lot of people set out blogging with their primary objective to make money, and a good product (content) is secondary.
This is exactly how a lot of businesses don't take off, or fail quickly.
In any business, blogging included, you should set out with your primary goal of creating a great product, and providing value to your customers. If you can succeed in doing this, the money will follow.
Money is simply a byproduct of a great value offering.
This is a fascinating post.
This is a fascinating post.
As a newer newbie to blogging, my posting timetable is still a bit erratic. I would ideally like to post at least twice a week but sometimes, my posts can get pretty long and require some research first. And then I find that a couple of times I'm stumped for post topics and can go for two weeks without writing a post.
However, what I've personally noticed is that whenever I post a new topic and announce it on Twitter and to the Twitter12 members, I get a small increase in traffic. It coincides precisely whenever I post a new post.
Tim Ferriss, author of "The 4-Hour Work Week" actually only posts twice a week at most. His reasoning is that it gives times for comments on a blog post to accumulate. If you post everyday, then post get pushed down the line before people notice them and have time to comment. So, he's obviously puts a high value on comments.
Different strokes for different folks I suppose.
I post on other peoples blogs out of loyalty to encourage them, especially members of Twitter12.
Cheers.
Gordie Rogers (Twitter12 member).
Gordie Rogers's last blog post... Tim Ferriss's Tools And Tricks You Need To Know.
Quality Content & Consistency
I always like reports which have data in'em, being statistics junkie I am. For some bloggers posting just once a week can be good enough (most likely the posts are longer then), and for some posting several times a day doesn't work. So I think that the key is quality content, bringing value to whatever topic you're writing about and being consistent about it.
Choose a schedule for your posts (once a day, every other day, 3 times a week, etc.) and stick with it. If you don't time/resources for it, don't try posting every day if you can't keep up (I did this at start and it was bad), I wish I'd saved and scheduled those posts and I'd had month worth of content "in the bank" at all times, now I only have some.
Zemalf's last blog post... Why Do You Blog?
I think you're right Zemalf,
I think you're right Zemalf, consistency is important to many people. I get frustrated with blogs in my RSS feeder that remain empty for a couple of weeks, then have a little spurt of posts.
Has anyone else tried "batching"? Writing a load of posts on one day, then scheduling them to publish? It works quite well for me, and I can then intersperse with newsy stuff.
Interesting about comments from Tim Ferris - hadn't thought of that angle before.
Mike
Batch blogging makes a great
Batch blogging makes a great deal of sense. I note with Live Writer you can schedule publication of posts - something to look into.
You can schedule posts in
You can schedule posts in Live writer with Wordpress. Sadly not with Drupal...
Mike